Tensions Flare over Welcoming Resolution

Bay City Commission meeting brings crowds on Monday over controversial debate

By Hal Reed

BAY CITY, Mich. – The community of Bay City gathered in front of City Hall to protest Immigration and Customs Enforcement policies, while counter-protestors voiced their support of ICE on Monday, Feb.18. Demonstrators on both sides held signs and chanted outside the building ahead of the commission meeting, calling on city leaders to clarify their stance on federal immigration enforcement.

Bay City Mayor Chris Girard vetoed a proposed “welcoming resolution” that would have designated Bay City as a community welcoming to all residents, regardless of immigration status, last March. The resolution also sought to prohibit the use of city officers, personnel and departments in the enforcement of federal immigration law. 

After residents voiced their concerns over the policy last year, Girard stated last week that the city could not afford to make decisions that put financial stability and essential services in jeopardy. Girard also said that vetoing the resolution was necessary to avoid potential legal conflicts and to ensure the city remains in compliance with state and federal regulations.

Almost a year later, the debate about becoming a “welcoming city” has roared back to life. Following the protests, both supporters and opponents entered the City Hall. The meeting filled every seat available, leaving standing room only. 

During the meeting, public comment dominated. Comments ranged from fears about immigrants in the community to concerns that welcoming ICE could bring scenes like those in Minnesota. 

As the meeting wound down and commissioners finished discussing the resolution, no solution came after five hours. The proposal was referred back to Commissioner Christopher Runberg for possible amendments to be added.