Misogyny or comedy?
SNL host Shane Gillis sprouts backlash from fans
By Isabelle Abraham
After comedian Shane Gillis hosted Saturday Night Live (SNL) on Oct. 10, fans were in an uproar over offensive jokes made too shortly following the Cornell 7 case.
For those that don’t know, the Cornell 7 case is a civil lawsuit against Cornell University. The case follows a sexual assault investigation of seven Chi Phi fraternity members after a student was allegedly drugged and gang-raped in the frat house.
During his monologue, Gillis shared that he had hit “fat rock bottom” and tried getting back into exercise. He started by discussing how he was on a solo hike when he came across another solo hiker, a woman, and tried his best to seem friendly so she wouldn’t feel unsafe. Then, he shared that he’s started going to the gym. He included a lot of self-deprecating jokes, but also a punchline that seemed to contradict his previous concern for women’s safety.
“I haven’t been to the gym in so long,” he said. “I didn’t know women just dressed like whores now. Have you seen the shorts? These neon, they’re like artificial bait colors. And the wrinkles go like around the cheeks and all combine at the butthole.”
Critics like Brenna Perez (@perezbrenna) on Instagram find Gillis’s version of comedy to be misogynistic, tone deaf and a reflection of a larger issue in society.
“Even if Shane Gillis wouldn’t do something to a woman on a hike or in any other scenario, this idea that workout clothes is somehow dressing like a whore is step one to the cultural normalization behind ‘well she was dressed like she was asking for it’,” Perez said in an Instagram post. “People are not being overly sensitive or unfunny by pointing out that this is very much a part of that problem.”
Gillis’s use of the word “bait” to describe women’s workout apparel also implies that women choose their clothing with the specific purpose to draw men in. In reality, women wear athletic wear to the gym because they’re working out. Athletic wear is designed to be comfortable, keep its wearer cool and stay out of the way.
Other users claim that Gillis was right about how women dress to the gym. Arguing that while some clothing is necessary to keep cool during a workout, it is undeniable that some women purposely wear immodest clothing to attract men.
On X, @heyyallitsHam shared a picture of women’s leggings that aligned with Gillis’s description.
“This is the kind of gym wear Shane Gillis was talking about in his monologue,” Ham said in an X post. “If women do not understand what this accentuates, they should not be allowed out of the house unattended.”
Others argue that Gillis was exercising his freedom of speech. They are concerned that preventing comedians from making controversial jokes can quickly head into censorship territory, which can threaten people’s first amendment rights.
Ian Lightfoot (@ianllightfoot), spoke about Shane Gillis and encouraged his audience to stand up to these harsh attempts at comedy.
“Just last week, when everyone was talking about Cornell, so many men said the same thing,” Lightfoot said in an Instagram post. “I want to be safe for women, but I don’t know how. Standing up to these jokes is literally how. This isn’t an isolated incident. These pathetic excuses for ‘jokes’ sound just like what’s consistently said in the locker room, or gaming, or with the boys. The culture might tell you to laugh, but I challenge you not to, even if it’s awkward.”
This controversy breaks down into two complicated questions: Does freedom of speech give comedians the right to make harmful jokes? Where do we draw the line between misogyny and comedy?
