‘Clayface’ review
The perfect blend of superhero and horror
By Parker Beckham
Ever since it was announced in 2024, “Clayface” has been one of my most anticipated movies to see recently. The film was confirmed early on to lean heavily into body horror, which is perfect for this character. Clayface is one of my favorite Batman villains, his tragic story has always piqued my interest. Finally seeing it unfold on the big screen was going to be a dream come true. After all of the hype and anticipation, I was left with one question: will it meet my expectations?
This movie is the third film installment of the newly started DC Cinematic Universe (DCU), a shared media franchise with a unified continuity across live action films, television, animation and video games. It is easily comparable to the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) that has been ongoing since 2008. However, “Clayface” is a standalone story in the DCU, which is exactly why I love it.
One of my biggest issues with the MCU is how every single film and TV show needs to be a building block for the next big movie. Don’t get me wrong, it’s extremely impressive how everything is so intertwined and leads to big movies such as “The Avengers.” But as a result, they sacrifice being able to tell deep, personal stories focusing on one character or group. Instead of being excited to see their favorite character on screen, people often only get excited for a new MCU movie to see how it will tie into the broad universe.
“Clayface” does not fall victim to this issue whatsoever, and I could not be happier. We don’t hear any reference to Superman. We don’t get a sneak peek at Batman. We don’t get anything of that sort. Rather, we get to entirely focus on the main character, Matt Hagen, and his physical and mental decline throughout the movie.
We watch Matt Hagen go from an academy award nominated actor, to a disfigured victim of gang violence. In hopes to regain his life back, he seeks out an intense, new type of facial reconstruction surgery. The effects are detrimental and eventually turns him into the disgusting, shapeshifting titular character that is Clayface. It doesn’t treat Hagen as an anti-hero either. The audience may root for him initially, but by the end it’s hard to even recognize him. We understand why he got to the point that he did. Even if we can’t root for him anymore, we still recognize how tragic his fall from grace was.
Unlike most blockbuster superhero flicks, “Clayface” has a relatively smaller budget. This forced the production crew to come up with creative workarounds to not go over budget. You would expect the smaller $44 million budget to restrict the film, but if anything, it elevated it. Not only has the low budget made it easy for the film to break even, but it also forced the crew to rely heavily on practical effects used very sparingly. The effects used to create Matt’s various deformities throughout the movie were almost all entirely practical and are insanely impressive. This gives the audience only mere glimpses at the horror of Matt’s disfigured, clay face.
Unfortunately, this also leads into my one big criticism of the movie. It isn’t nearly as scary as I was expecting. This film was heavily advertised as a body horror, implying it focused more on disturbing imagery opposed to typical horror movie elements. Even so, I couldn’t help but think it was a little tame. While the effects were all incredibly well done, there were really only a couple times I felt squeamish in my chair.
Other than the tame body horror, I loved this movie, and I cannot recommend it enough. It was both an amazing comic book and horror movie that lovers of either genre would enjoy. This film has stuck with me since I saw it on opening day. The more I think about it the more I love it. “Clayface” has so much to offer and is nearly impossible to not enjoy. The movie is a scarily good time that has potential to be considered the best horror movie of 2026.
