Before a stranger says a word
Freedom of speech protects opinions, but does not justify prejudice
By Grace McCarthy
All vulgar language is a direct quote regarding mentioned social media incident.
A video shared on Saginaw’s Reddit page has struck up controversy at Delta College. The video shows Chloe Duranso, a prerequisite student at Delta, describing violence against any Muslim stranger without explaining what that person has done wrong.
Seated in a car, Duranso talks about losing rights due to the midterm results. She questions what Michigan’s US senator-elect, Abdul El-Sayed, would do, emphasizing that he is “a fucking Muslim man.”
Then the conversation moves from politics to her car window. Duranso describes the steps she’d take if someone who was Muslim approached.
“They’re getting fucking killed,” Duranso said. “I swear to God, I’ll hit them with my damn car.”
Duranso does not give reasoning for her words of violence. She does not say if they have a weapon or are trying to hurt her in any way. In the hypothetical encounter she describes, being Muslim and approaching her window is enough.
That missing explanation matters. Duranso goes from naming someone’s religion to describing their death without any hesitation of what they have done to deserve her anger.
Later, she predicts that “they” will try to make people participate in Muslim prayer. Duranso offers no evidence for that claim. She gives zero explanation of why a stranger at her window would be responsible.
Instead, Duranso seems to speak as though someone’s religion alone is enough to determine whether they should be feared.
Someone who shares that belief would watch this TikTok without giving it much thought. A Muslim viewer could be left with a different question: Would she mean me?
We cannot know how everyone will react to this video. But nobody should have to consider that their neighbor claims their religion as a reason to hurt them.
This is what gets lost when we judge people before we get the chance to know them. A stranger’s life is worth more than a few seconds of opinion. They have families waiting for them, people who love them and futures to look forward to.
Prejudice and political polarization let us ignore all of that. It allows us to look at someone we have never met and decide we already know enough.
It can be easier to hate than to be kind. Hate can go unchallenged when the people around us share it. Kindness sometimes asks more of us. Kindness asks us to see a person beyond what we assume about the color of their skin or the religion they choose to believe in.
Freedom of speech leaves room for beliefs we find offensive. It also leaves room to challenge them, especially when they involve threats towards other people.
No one needs to agree with Islam to recognize that a person’s religious beliefs don’t make their life any less valuable. Criticizing a religion does not make every person who practices it a threat. A stranger’s faith alone is no reason to assume they’ll harm you.
Duranso’s concern about losing her rights contradicts her own statements. She is in fear of what someone might take from her while describing how she would take someone else’s life.
The video ends, but the person watching still has to move forward.
A Muslim viewer will go to work, grocery shop or simply pick up their kids from school knowing someone has publicly described a willingness to kill a person of their religion on sight.
They deserve to know that the community finds this distasteful. It’s possible to disagree with someone’s beliefs without deciding their life matters less.
